Shaw Trust’s CEO Chris Luck shares his reflections on Alan Milburn’s NEETs report.
The Milburn Review has been a been a year in the making, shaped by extensive consultation with young people, employers, practitioners and policymakers.
It’s perhaps no surprise then, that the report reflects many of the things we see every day. People rarely experience challenges in isolation. Health, skills, confidence, housing, work and opportunity are all connected. Yet the support available to them is usually fragmented across multiple funding streams, services and organisations.
The recommendations are ambitious and the Government has already signalled its intention to act. The focus now shifts towards delivery.
At its heart, this is a report about integration, and much of this will feel familiar to those already working with Shaw Trust. Through our own strategy, we’ve been bringing together employment, health and skills support, delivering integrated services locally and developing new approaches for those young people facing the greatest barriers to participation.
With that in mind, five questions matter most:
1. Can we build one system from many services?
Young people shouldn’t have to navigate a maze of disconnected services. Employment support, health services, skills provision and wider support all sitting separately.
The principle behind the Youth Opportunity Service is right. Young people should not have to understand how the system works in order to access help.
We know this can work. Through our partnership with the West London Alliance, people access support through a single front door, connecting them to the provision available locally. They are assessed once, triaged appropriately and connected to the support that best meets their needs.
The opportunity now is to move from examples of good practice to a system where joined-up support becomes the norm. That is exactly the challenge our own strategy is designed to help policy makers and commissioners address.
2. Can we build support around people, not programmes?
The report repeatedly reminds us that there is no single route into work.
Some young people need support with their health. Others need help building skills, confidence or experience. Many need support across several areas at the same time.
Rolling out Individual Placement and Support for Young People (IPS-Y) will be an important part of the answer. IPS-Y starts with the person, bringing together employment and health support around their goals.
We also recognise that this type of support will not be right for every young person. Our Reframe trial highlights that some young people need a different starting point before they are ready to take practical steps towards developing their skills, or gaining paid work.
Local areas cannot rely on a single programme, but need to build the right mix of support around the needs of the young people in their communities.
3. How do we make devolution work everywhere?
One of the review’s biggest bets is on local leadership. Proposals such local Participation Plans and the Youth Opportunity Service recognise that ultimately participation is delivered locally.
Many of the strongest examples of joined-up support already come from places where commissioners, health services, community organisations, employment support providers and employers are working together towards shared outcomes.
We know this can work. The question is how we make it work everywhere. As we saw from ERSA’s recent Connect to Work review improvements have to be made if we’re going to get high quality services everywhere. We’re looking for all commissioners to act boldly to match the ambition of this report.
To fulfil its promise, devolution cannot become a postcode lottery. Local leadership must be matched by capability, capacity and long-term thinking by drawing on the expertise and knowledge partners can provide.
4. How do we create more opportunities for young people?
Milburn’s central argument is that young people need more opportunities.
They need multiple routes into work, including apprenticeships, training, meaningful work experience and supported employment. They also need earlier exposure to those opportunities, with earlier careers conversations to give them a clearer understanding of their options.
Preparing someone for work is only half the challenge. The other half is making sure opportunities exist when they are ready.
Employers are central here. The report rightly recognises the importance of creating more first opportunities into work, particularly for those who may lack experience but have significant potential.
Large employers have an important role to play, but so do the thousands of smaller businesses creating jobs in local communities. Many will need support themselves if they are to recruit and retain young people, particularly those with additional barriers to work.
Creating more opportunities will require schools, colleges, employers and local partners working together to create clear pathways into good work locally. We’ve already been bringing learning, skills and experience together through our work-based study programmes for young people who are NEET, including many SEND learners. Our range of apprenticeships are providing practical routes into employment, with 50% studying towards entry level qualifications at Levels 2 and 3.
5. How do we protect young people’s needs while the new system is being created?
The most debated aspects of the review are its proposals around welfare reform, participation and the creation of a new Youth Allowance.
The report is clear that support and opportunity should come before reform. Through measures such as the Opportunity Guarantee, Support Guarantee and Youth Opportunity Service, it seeks to create clearer routes into work, education and training.
Many of the young people we’re talking about are managing poor mental health, disability, long-term health conditions or multiple disadvantages. That means it has to be done in the right way.
We support a stronger participation expectation. However, conditionality only works where genuine opportunities, personalised support and safeguards exist first.
Government must get the balance between opportunity, responsibility and protection right.
What happens next.
The Milburn Review presents a real opportunity to fundamentally change how young people access opportunities. We know many of these approaches can work because we see the difference they make every day.
The challenge now is how we create the system to make sure more young people can benefit from them. At the same time, we can’t forget about future proofing the system – we need to make sure that it can adapt to changing needs within a community or the type of people it is aiming to support.
That is why Shaw Trust continues to provide services which bring together employment, health and skills, centred around people’s needs and delivered through integrated local provision.


